LP SmartSide vs. Hardie Board: Engineered Wood or Fiber Cement?

How engineered wood and fiber cement compare on price and paint, and where the wildfire code can settle the choice for a house near Fort Collins.

Blue-gray lap siding with a wood-grain texture meeting white window trim marked in pencil, with a yellow tape measure and a pencil resting on the sill

Quick Answer

LP SmartSide is engineered wood siding from one maker, and Hardie board, or James Hardie siding, is a name many people use for fiber cement, borrowed from one of its makers. As for which siding is better for your home, Hardie board or LP SmartSide, that depends more on the house than on the name. Priced on the same house, engineered wood tends to cost less. On unincorporated Larimer County land, the county's fire rules for siding name cement-based siding such as fiber cement and require wood-based siding to be fire-treated at the factory, and for a house there that can settle it.

How LP SmartSide and Hardie Board Compare

Fort Collins Siding Contractors puts up both engineered wood and fiber cement, so what follows compares the two materials, whoever made them. Once they're painted, either one can pass for a wall of painted wood lap boards.

Engineered wood siding, such as LP SmartSideFiber cement siding, such as Hardie board
What it's made ofWood fibers and resinCement, sand and wood fibers
Comes asLap boards, panels and shake-style lapLap boards, panels and shingles
ColorComes primed to be painted, or with a factory finishComes primed to be painted, or with a factory finish
Typical whole-house price around Fort Collins$9,000 to $22,000$15,000 to $30,000

Both prices are for a whole house that has somewhere around 1,250 to 2,000 square feet of siding, and they include the tear-off and the new trim. If soft sheathing turns up behind the old siding, that's an added cost on top of the range.

Which One Suits Your House

  • Where the house sits. On unincorporated Larimer County land, Laporte included, the county's rules treat the two differently: fiber cement is named as a fire-resistant siding, while engineered wood, being wood-based, would need a fire-retardant treatment done at the factory. Our Laporte page explains when that rule comes into a re-side. Inside Fort Collins, the wildfire code comes into play when a re-side covers a quarter of the walls or more, and only in the parts of the city the state maps as wildfire interface. For a house in either place, we'd check whether the engineered wood you're looking at meets the code at your address before pricing it. Anywhere else in the city, the wildfire code doesn't come into the choice.
  • What you'd like to spend. The two price ranges overlap, so a small, plain house in fiber cement can cost about what a big house with a lot of gables does in engineered wood.
  • Upkeep. Both end up as painted siding, and sooner or later either one will need repainting.

More on this: Engineered Wood Siding in Fort Collins

LP SmartSide vs. Hardie Questions in Fort Collins

Who are the best siding manufacturers?

There isn't one maker that's best for every house. Each of the two makers named here sells its siding in more than one style and finish. We'd start with the material that suits your house and the rules at your address, and then go through the products in that material that fit your budget.

Curious What Each Would Run for Your House?

Give us an idea of which way you're leaning and roughly where the house sits. We'll come out and see the house with you, then give you a written price for either material, or both. If the wildfire code reaches your address, what it calls for on the walls goes on the estimate too.

Get a Free Estimate
  • Free estimates
  • 10+ years of experience
  • Licensed
  • Insured