The Best Siding for Hail in Colorado
What hail does to vinyl, wood and older aluminum siding, how each kind of siding is fixed after a storm, and how that can steer the one you choose.

Quick Answer
With hail in mind, we'd choose siding for a Colorado house by how easily a damaged piece can be replaced and blended in after a storm, along with the price and the rules where the house sits. On siding that has been painted on the house, whether it's wood, fiber cement or engineered wood, a new board can be painted to match the wall around it. Vinyl comes in its color from the factory, so on vinyl that has weathered, a new panel can look out of place.
What Hail Does to the Siding on a Colorado House
After a hailstorm has you pricing new siding, it's natural to want the kind that will handle the next one best. Fort Collins Siding Contractors can side a house in fiber cement, engineered wood, vinyl, or wood and cedar, and this is what we can tell you about how hail treats them, along with the older aluminum siding that's still on some houses.
- Vinyl can crack or break. A hailstone can crack a vinyl panel or break a piece out of it, and on a wall that took a lot of hail, those cracks and holes can be spread across several panels.
- Wood can crack or dent. Hail can crack a wood board or leave a dent in it, and where the wood is dented, the paint over it can be damaged too.
- Older aluminum dents. If your house still has aluminum siding, it's the siding hail damages most easily, and the damage shows up as dents.

Fiber cement and engineered wood. Much of what you'll read about how these two take hail comes from the companies that make them, and we don't pass along a maker's claims. What we can tell you is how they're fixed. Both are painted siding, finished at the factory or after they go up, so a damaged board can be replaced and then painted or touched up to blend with the wall around it.
How Each Kind of Siding Is Fixed After Hail
Each of these can be repaired after a storm by replacing only the damaged pieces, though older aluminum can be hard to replace. Where they differ most is in how well the new piece blends in with the old.
| Siding | A storm-damaged piece | How well a new piece blends in |
|---|---|---|
| Vinyl | Comes out by itself, and the panels around it stay up | It comes colored, so on weathered vinyl a new panel can look brighter |
| Wood and cedar | Replaced board by board | Painted wood blends in easily, since the new board and the wall get the same paint |
| Fiber cement | Replaced board by board | Painted or touched up once it's in |
| Engineered wood | Replaced board by board | Painted or touched up once it's in |
| Older aluminum | Can be hard to replace | It comes colored, and a close match can be hard to find |
So if you'd like a future hail repair to be hard to spot, siding that's painted on the house can have the edge, as long as you're glad to repaint every few years.
What Else Steers the Choice Around Fort Collins
Hail is one thing to weigh, and the rules where your house sits can count for as much. Inside Fort Collins city limits, new vinyl goes over a fire-rated wall that isn't in vinyl's usual price, so there it costs more than it first looks. In Laporte and the rest of unincorporated Larimer County, the county's wildfire rules decide what new siding has to be, and our Laporte page goes through them.
For the repair itself, after this storm or the next one, see Hail Damage Siding Repair in Fort Collins.
Hail Resistant Siding in Colorado
What kind of siding is hail proof?
None that we'd call hail-proof. Fort Collins writes impact resistance into its building code for roofs, requiring impact-resistant shingles when half or more of a roof is replaced, but it sets no impact rating for siding.
Choosing New Siding for a House That Sees Hail?
Tell us what's on the house now and what the last hailstorm did to it. Once we've looked at the walls with you, we'll go over how each siding you're weighing would be repaired after the next storm, and give you a written price for each.
Get a Free Estimate- Free estimates
- 10+ years of experience
- Licensed
- Insured
